1211: Conspiracy Theories | Skeptical Sunday

1211: Conspiracy Theories | Skeptical Sunday

This transcript is yet untouched by human hands. Please proceed with caution as we sort through what the robots have given us. We appreciate your patience!

Jordan Harbinger: [00:00:00] Welcome to Skeptical Sunday. I'm your host, Jordan Harbinger. Today I am here with Skeptical Sunday co-host skeptic and comedian Michael Lio on the Jordan Harbinger Show. We decode the stories, secrets, and skills of the world's most fascinating people and turn their wisdom into practical advice that you can use to impact your own life and those around you.

Our mission is to help you become a better informed, more critical thinker. And during the week, we have long form conversations with a variety of amazing folks from spies to CEOs, athletes, authors, thinkers, and performers. On Sundays, though it's skeptical Sunday, where a rotating guest, co-host and I breakdown a topic you may have never thought about and debunk common misconceptions about that topic.

Such as Why tipping Makes no sense Circumcision, e-commerce scams, diet supplements, the lottery, Reiki, healing, ear Candling. Those got a lot of emails as you might imagine, internet porn, hypnosis, homeopathy, and more. If you're new to the show or you wanna tell your friends about the show, I suggest our episode Starter Packs.

These are collections of our favorite episodes on persuasion, negotiation, psychology, [00:01:00] disinformation, junk science, crime, and cults and more. That'll help new listeners get a taste of everything we do here on the show. Just visit Jordan harbinger.com/start or search for us in your Spotify app. To get started today on the show seems like more and more as we scroll social media, we find out that this professional athlete thinks the earth is flat, that rapper thinks vaccines enlarged her cousins testicles.

Conspiracy theories have gone from the far corners of the internet to front and center of everyone's social media feed. This topic is equal parts fascinating, frustrating, and downright frightening, in my opinion. From the moon landing hoax to Q anon to Jewish space lasers. Why do they have to be Jewish?

I guess we'll find out. We're tracing the strange, often dangerous path of the human imagination when it gets tangled up with fear, tribalism, and bad information. Comedian and skeptic, maybe in that order. Michael Lio is here to help us get to the bottom of why so many people believe in conspiracies. What makes these theories so compelling?

And how can we separate healthy skepticism from full [00:02:00] blown paranoia? Hey, Jordan. Uh, tell me, do you

MIchael Regilio: believe in any conspiracy theories? It depends on what you mean by conspiracy theories. One widely accepted definition defines it as an explanatory belief that secret malevolent groups acting in concert cause significant events despite weak or contrary evidence.

The no, not really. Do you believe in them? Oh, yeah. I mean, I used to believe in a bunch of them. Let's start with the classic that America never went to the moon. I believed this of course, because there's no way we went to the moon. I mean, hello waving flag in a vacuum.

Jordan Harbinger: Well, first of all, I thought we were gonna be skeptical of conspiracy theories on this episode.

MIchael Regilio: Sorry. The young man that lives in my brain still gets out from time to time. Sure, of course. I don't believe that. But it was a conspiracy theory that I once believed and I believed it for good reasons because I saw a television show about it.

Jordan Harbinger: Yeah, great reason. So I think I may have seen the same [00:03:00] show though.

Everybody kind of saw that back then and most of us were smart enough not to take it to heart, but here we are.

MIchael Regilio: Yeah. But uh, look, that was old me. That is to say, that was young me. I was all in. Now, in my defense, this may have been because I was under 25 and my prefrontal cortex wasn't fully formed, which is one reason for believing in conspiracy theories.

Again, this is something we're about to get into, but let's just say it's more likely you believe in conspiracy theories when you're young, particularly a young man, because the young male brain literally isn't capable of processing all the information properly,

Jordan Harbinger: right? The prefrontal cortex, I believe we've talked about this before a few times on the show.

It's kind of the final addition to the human brain. Evolutionarily speaking. It's actually fully developed in young women before it fully develops in young men, which surprises probably no

MIchael Regilio: one.

Yeah,

definitely not me. And I think I actually mentioned this in a previous episode as well, but when I was a young [00:04:00] man, I jumped off an 80 foot cliff into a quarry and blew my eardrums out.

Oof. Now you could blame that on me being stupid, but I blame it on the fact that my prefrontal cortex wasn't fully formed and I didn't have critical thinking skills yet. That said, that very still developing prefrontal cortex that stopped me from making good decisions also allowed me to fall for some pretty crazy ideas like the moon landing hoax.

Just because I saw a very slanted television show. And I will tell you this though, I stopped believing in that one for as bad of reasons as I started believing in it. Somebody I respected made fun of me.

Jordan Harbinger: Fine. I make fun of you all the time. Haven't noticed you changed your mind on much. Maybe it has.

Maybe the respect part is the missing. The

MIchael Regilio: missing link. That's right. I stand by my statement that said. I was in the full throes of the Neil Armstrong Buzz Aldrin, our liars stage of my life. Oh my

Jordan Harbinger: God.

MIchael Regilio: And at that time, my girlfriend took me to [00:05:00] a comedy show to see a famous comedian she was friends with.

After the show, we all went to a bar and I started shooting my mouth off about how America never went to the moon. The famous comedian did what comedians do best and Roasted the living shit...

Jordan Harbinger: Yeah.

MIchael Regilio: ...Out of me in front of everyone. I believe he called me the dumbest person he had ever met. So I went home feeling pretty roasted, pretty burned.

Mm-hmm. You name it. And I never mentioned the moon hoax again, and I slowly started looking into it. It's hard for me to admit this Jordan, but there's some chance I was, in fact, the dumbest person ever and we totally went to the moon.

Jordan Harbinger: The skeptical atheist origin story, something tells me you're not the first one to have been essentially scorned into your skepticism and scorned out of your dumb beliefs.

MIchael Regilio: Oh, I wish that was the end of it for me. Again, not easy for me to admit this, but around the turn of the century, my friend showed me a film that both reignited my interest in conspiracy theories, but. [00:06:00] It also gave me the final nail to drive into the coffin of conspiracy thinking for me forever. Turn of the century, eh?

Jordan Harbinger: Okay. Oh boy. I seem to recall a rather poignant, important historical event around that time that birthed some of the most persistent conspiracy theories of all time. I'm no psychic, but let me see if I can read your mind. Was the film called Loose Change? Yep. Yeah. Nailed it. So the guy here that I brought here to dispel conspiracy theories.

Is a former moon lending Hoaxer nine 11 Truther. Great. We are scraping the bottom of the skeptic barrel over here, man. Come on.

MIchael Regilio: Okay. Look, again, my nine 11 truther days were very short-lived and it was because of the film loose change that I finally found the keys to unlock the skepticism on conspiracy theories forever.

'cause I was watching loose change and rather than getting upset by the truth that America had attacked itself on nine [00:07:00] 11, I was getting excited, like I was feeling powerful. My heart was racing and I thought to myself, oh dude, I've got a secret truth, but I need to get out to the world. I'm not just some loser sitting in front of my laptop.

I'm a hero with a secret truth. That was it. The second I realized I was feeling that I realized why I wanted to believe this, like my motivations became clear. In that moment, I began looking into all the very good counter arguments to all the very bad conspiratorial arguments. I learned how to debunk.

Jordan Harbinger: You believed, and then went, ah, okay. This is motivated reasoning. That's interesting. I would imagine people believe in conspiracy theories for a bunch of different reasons. Not only that,

MIchael Regilio: oh, for sure they do. But hold on, before we get into the psychology of why people believe in conspiracy theories and even the neuroscience of why people believe in conspiracy theories.

Let's go back and take a look at the history of conspiracy theories. All right, let's [00:08:00] connect some dots. Okay, so I'm sure we could go all the way back to the beginning of the human race just based on how the human brain works. No doubt, one of the earliest tribes of humans blamed one of the other earliest tribes of humans for, I don't know, the crops failing or something.

But for our purposes, let's go back to a persistent theme throughout conspiracy theories and its earliest incarnation that is blaming the Jews.

Jordan Harbinger: Okay.

MIchael Regilio: Now this hateful and terrible conspiracy takes on like a ton of narratives, but let's start with blood libel. Okay. We're off to a rather dark start. I know a little bit about this.

In a nutshell, it's the idea that Jewish people murder Christian children and use the blood for rituals. And I wish I was making this up because it's so stupid that I'm shocked anyone would ever have believed it. But they also, that Jews would use the Christian blood of children for making matza bread.

Jordan Harbinger: Okay, well [00:09:00] that's really just so stupid. I wanna make a joke, but I also know where this is going and I know it's no joking matter, but Christian children, blood bread, I mean like Masa's White, first of all. I guess logic never really tends to permeate these ideas too much, but where does the blood go if the bread is white?

I mean, it's, the whole thing is dumb. Yeah, super dumb.

MIchael Regilio: Look, the idea of accusing Jews, of murdering children, the so-called blood libel actually goes way, way back. You can find references as early as the second, or century BCE, in the writings of Appian, but it really took off in medieval Europe after Christianity spread, especially in the 12th century following the first Crusades.

So the first big case was in Norwich, England in 1144. A boy named William was found dead in the woods and the local Jewish community was accused of killing him. The story went that they took a Christian child before Easter and tortured him the same way Jesus was tortured, then hanged him on Good Friday.

Jordan Harbinger: Uh, it wasn't a good Friday for [00:10:00] William. Uh, sorry. Stops. Anyway, yeah, horrible, sickening stuff. And I'll be honest, when I first saw that we were gonna do conspiracy theories today, I kind of imagined we would have a good laugh. You know, I wasn't expecting it to be this dark. So early in the show, I'm kind of dreading where things go from here.

MIchael Regilio: You know what, that's the thing about conspiracy theories, although most of them are laughable. When you peel back the layers of this onion, like all onions, you start to cry. So as the Middle Ages went on, the blood libel myth really spread. It even got mixed up with other accusations, like claims that Jews were poisoning the wells.

Jordan Harbinger: Yeah, sadly, I've heard of that one too. The whole poisoning of the wells thing. I guess back then they didn't understand the relationship between microbes and standing water and all that stuff. Yeah.

MIchael Regilio: Well, you know what? Even if they had understood those things, they still would've blamed the Jews because sadly the conspiracy was in some ways financially motivated because Europe was under the grips of the Black Death rumors abounded, because as you [00:11:00] said, they didn't know about microbes or germs or rats carrying germs.

So they, the Jewish population claiming they poisoned the wells to kill Christians. The Jewish population at the time often lived, separated from the Christian population because, well, you know, good old fashioned antisemitism. Sure. But because of both their isolation and the fact that they had stricter hygiene practices than their Christian counterparts, they may well have had lower death rates, which just further fueled the fear

Jordan Harbinger: that is so twisted, Hey, you can't live among us.

But also, why are you lot not also getting the very communicable disease that the rest of us are dying from? Come on.

MIchael Regilio: Yeah, for sure. And to make things worse, because you know it was the dark ages, they would also grab some Jewish people and torture them into giving confessions. Oh. And they would then use those confessions as evidence that the Jewish people were in fact.

Poisoning the wells in rivers.

Jordan Harbinger: I hate this conspiracy theory. This one's making me sick.

MIchael Regilio: Tell me we got fun ones later on. Do we have fun ones later on? We do have fun [00:12:00] ones later on, but I have to warn you that this one's about to get even sicker because All right. At that time, Pope Clement the six actually tried to stop this madness pointing out that the Jews were also dying of the plague, but his attempts fell on deaf ears because it was politically convenient to blame Jews and allowed local authorities to cancel debts owed to Jewish lenders.

Jordan Harbinger: I heard about this. This is pretty gross, pushing something as disgusting as that just for money. But this actually, this happened to Jews in a lot of countries. At a lot of times, I think entire royal empires, Spain or Portugal, whatever they borrowed from Jewish lenders and then blamed them for some nonsense, like a plot or whatever in order to get themselves off the hook for paying the debt.

Then they'd just be like, we gotta get rid of all these Jews so that they don't try to collect on the money we've borrowed from them. I think again, Spain, Portugal, somebody correct me on this, but possibly elsewhere, I'm going off memory. It might have even happened in all this might be an all of the above kind of kind of thing and not a either or kind of thing would surprise me.

MIchael Regilio: Yeah, [00:13:00] we're about to see that. A great many people might not believe the conspiracy theories they propagate, but push them anyway because of money.

Gay Frogs Clip: I don't like them putting chemicals in the water that turn the frigging frogs gay.

MIchael Regilio: That guy. Yes, him. So you see, if you had a time machine and you could have gone back and talked to them about microbes and germs and rats, they would've found something else to blame.

The other on which we'll get into as we discuss the psychology of conspiracy theories, a lot of it comes from the fact that we are still very tribal. The medieval Europeans had found their tribe, the Christian tribe, which meant blaming the non-Christian tribe for their problems. One of

Jordan Harbinger: the other tribes of note was what the Jews at this point in time.

MIchael Regilio: Oh yeah. Were tribal and I'm sure Medieval Christian Europeans othered. Quite a few other populations, but yeah. Yeah. Let's get onto where this was going. 'cause it, it ballooned in medieval Europe. Another famous case was in Trent, Italy in 1475, a little boy [00:14:00] named Simon went missing around Easter and his father accused the local Jewish community of killing him to use his blood to make matza again.

Yeah. For Passover.

Jordan Harbinger: I so wonder how many of these are like parents killing their children and then being like the Jews. Trust me, bro. Oh, that is such a good point, right? Like, why is the first go-to must have been the Jews? Not like, yeah, we have a serial killer on the loose around here. Clearly. Or like, he went hiking all the time alone and he's missing now.

I mean, it just seems weird to go straight to the Jews or,

MIchael Regilio: or he, you know, ruined a, a good, I don't know, bucket and the father beat him to death.

Jordan Harbinger: Yeah. He's definitely not buried under the cornfield or anything. So blame the Jews. This conspiracy theory now, if you look at it, is stretching from William of Norwich in 11, whatever, just Simon or Simone or whatever of Trent across all of Europe at this point, over the centuries.

I don't know why the stupidity of the idea that Jews were killing Christian children to bake bread is bumming me out so much. It, it's, it's so dumb. I know that like we're gonna think things we believe now were dumb or whatever, but [00:15:00] like God people back then, just so stupid, so fricking ignorant and stupid.

Holy smokes.

MIchael Regilio: Yeah. Well, I got news for you. You're probably gonna be experiencing a lot of that particular emotion in this episode. All right. Now, in poor little Simon's case, people started claiming miracles were happening after his death, and they attributed them to Simon or the ghost of Simon, or the spirit of Simon or whatever.

However, miracles worked. He was even canonized into sainthood by the Catholic church, though the Vatican removed little Simon Sainthood in 1965. That's rough

Jordan Harbinger: removing the sainthood of little Simon. You wonder what, what does it take for them to be like, you know what? Nah, not this one. It's been done for, it's like a thousand years ago, man. Chill. 500 years ago. What's the point?

MIchael Regilio: Yeah, those miracles couldn't have been Simon. We figured it out. But, uh, anyway, look, connect the dots. Jordan Sainthood is just one big conspiracy anyway, but sometimes the conspiracy theorist becomes the one conspiracies theorize about, as we'll see with [00:16:00] the Catholics and the

Jordan Harbinger: Popish plot.

The Popish plot, I'm not even sure I know what the word Popish means. Never heard that

MIchael Regilio: Popish is an old, derogatory word, meaning relating to the Pope or Roman Catholic Church. Nowadays, actually people still use it or refers to somebody who's a mediocre songwriter. Oh yeah, man. I guess that song's okay.

I don't know if I'd call it Pop.

Jordan Harbinger: Oh my

MIchael Regilio: god.

Jordan Harbinger: Pop ish. Yeah, that joke is dumb ish. All right, continue. Keep going. Away from this, away from this nonsense.

MIchael Regilio: Okay. In 1678, England was crypt with a conspiracy theory that was part religious hysteria, part political manipulation, and completely outright lies A disgrace, clergyman by the name of Titus Oats, kind of a badass name.

Jordan Harbinger: Yeah, it sounds like a, a ban from the sixties or seventies, but continue.

MIchael Regilio: It predated Hall and Oats. It was, it was oats as first, that's band. Titus os. That's, I'm thinking, that's, that's why I'm thinking it. Yeah. Titus Oats. Anyway, so Titus Oats claimed, uh, he had unearthed the sinister Catholic plot to murder the king.[00:17:00]

He claimed that priests were planning to murder King Charles ii. So his brother, James Duke of York, a Catholic could ascend to the throne. Titus Oats also claimed that the Catholics were planning to massacre all the Protestants. Just to put the scare and the hate into the general population.

Jordan Harbinger: Yeah. 'cause you know, if you just say, Hey, there's a plot to kill the king, I think there's a decent chance most of the population might be like, okay, or just outright cool with it.

Or ask How can I help? Yeah. Hey, do you need a hand? But if you add an oh and also they're gonna kill all of you guys too. Then it's like, oh, right recipe for mass hysteria. It sounds a little bit like Game of Thrones. I'm surprised there's not some HBO series about this.

MIchael Regilio: Oh man. It would actually make a pretty good show 'cause things go nuts.

See, anti-Catholic sentiment was already pretty high in Europe at the time because of religious conflict within the country. At least 22 innocent priests were hanged suspicion, also hung everywhere. Even Queen Catherine of [00:18:00] Braganza. Who was Charles second's wife who was a Catholic, was accused of treason.

The whole country was going nuts with the paranoia. So by 1681 though, the whole thing had been uncovered as a complete lie, and the conspiracy unraveled, the tables turned and it was tightest oats walking through the streets of London while being whipped in front of everyone, and ultimately he was imprisoned.

Jordan Harbinger: Wow. So that really happened. There it is. Man. Game of Thrones. It's hard to imagine that really being a thing. I Maybe we should bring that back. Some people kind of need that, I think.

MIchael Regilio: Yeah, I know. Hey, not everything they used to do was bad. I mean, nowadays it's called canceling and forget it. I mean, you see it.

The internet all the time. It needs to

Jordan Harbinger: be like a trial. I, I know some judges do this. Have you seen this? Some judges make, like, have you shoplift? They're like, you're out. You have one year of probation. But also you're spending every Saturday wearing a sign, a sandwich board that says, I shoplifted from Target and you have to stand outside Target.

No way. No, I haven't seen that. Yeah, it's controversial of [00:19:00] course. 'cause some people are like, well, it's cruel and unusual. And it's like, no, no, no. Thumbscrews are cruel and unusual being castrated. Uh, it might be cruel and unusual. You standing outside of Target with a sign that says I'm a shoplifter is not cruel and unusual.

In fact, it's way less than what you tried to do to this business and you might need to have your reputation besmirched.

MIchael Regilio: That is crazy. Yeah. What's crazy to me is, as you say, it is like they think that's cruel and unusual, but go to prison where uh, there's a pretty good chance you will be raped and there's nothing we can do about it that's not cruel and unusual.

Jordan Harbinger: I would much rather wear the sandwich board than be like hanging out with people who settled disputes by blinding you with soap or whatever the hell like, or beating you with some kind of pipe that they've found. No. I'll take the sandwich board. Thank you.

MIchael Regilio: Yeah. Or shitting you in the back with a sharpened spoon.

Jordan Harbinger: Whenever I do these interviews with guys who've been through prison, I can't remember who this was, it might've been like Ricky Freeway. Ricky Ross or whatever, but he was like, yeah, I knew this guy was gonna kill me.

So I tucked [00:20:00] magazines into my pants under my shirt and that was like, his body armor was these thick magazines and when they stabbed him it wouldn't go through the, his kidney area 'cause he had like a men's health stacked in there or something. Right. Like a bodybuilding magazine or I dunno, game pro, whatever, stuck in his pants.

It's like, no, I'll take the sandwich board, man. Any day of

MIchael Regilio: the week. Continue. Yeah. Don't get me started on prison. I've watched too many prison docs and uh, the craziest I ever saw is such a side note here, but in some juvenile hall, I believe it was where people would empty the toilet in their cell because they could talk to the people in the cell below them.

It was called talking on the bowl. And they would just hang out all day talking into a toilet. And then the person in the cell below them could talk into their toilet and it was like, basically like, you know, kids do with the cups and the string or something like that. What if you

Jordan Harbinger: have to go to the bathroom?

You just fill the toilet back up and flush and then empty, fill the toilet back

MIchael Regilio: up the, you know, roommate or cellmate or whatever does their business. And then you empty it again and go back [00:21:00] to talking on the bowl. And you could tell somebody had been talking on the bowl too much because they would have like rash all around their face and their mouth anyway.

Jordan Harbinger: Oh, that's so disgusting. And can you imagine like, hang on Tim, I gotta call you back. John's gotta take a dump. And then it's like after that, you know that that person just used like some container to dump every, oh God, I don't even want to continue this. Just take my mind off of this with something less disgusting. Q Anon promised secret codes, secret cabals, and secret revelations. All we've got here though are discount codes, but hey, at least those are actually real. We'll be right back. This episode is sponsored in part by ZipRecruiter. Hiring is a grind. You post a job, you sit there waiting for the right people to apply.

Meanwhile, you're sorting through a stack of resumes that don't even fit well. The future of hiring looks much brighter because ZipRecruiter's latest tools and features help speed up finding the right people for your roles, so you save valuable time. And now you can try ZipRecruiter for free at ziprecruiter.com/jordan.

Here's what I like with ZipRecruiter's new advances. [00:22:00] You can actually find and connect with qualified candidates in minutes, and if you see someone you really wanna talk to, you can unlock their contact info instantly. No waiting around, no dead ends. Plus, they're constantly adding fresh talent. Over 320,000 new resumes every month.

That's a ton of people actively looking, which means you can fill your roles sooner. It's no wonder ZipRecruiter is rated the number one hiring site on G two. So if you're hiring, don't waste weeks hoping the right candidate finds you. Go to ziprecruiter.com/jordan and make it easy on yourself.

Jen Harbinger: Use ZipRecruiter and save time.

Hiring four out of five employers who post on ZipRecruiter. Get a quality candidate within the first day, and if you go to ziprecruiter.com/jordan right now, you can try it for free. Again, that's ziprecruiter.com/jordan. ZipRecruiter, the smartest way to hire.

Jordan Harbinger: This episode is also sponsored by SimpliSafe.

Jen's cousin had their place broken into a couple weeks ago, and the thing is, they live in what you would think is a very safe neighborhood. Nice houses, quiet streets. They even had cameras and an alarm system set up, but it wasn't tied to a monitoring service, and that theft turned out to be a real wake up [00:23:00] call.

By the time the alarm went off, the intruder was inside, and by the time police showed up, these three low lives were long gone with a quite a bit of valuables. And the problem with traditional security is it reacts after the damage is already done. That's why we recommend SimpliSafe. They built their system to be proactive, not reactive.

Their active guard. Outdoor protection actually spots a potential threat before it happens. The cameras know the difference between say a cat and a person lurking outside. And if it's the ladder, simply safes monitoring agents jump in right away using two-way audio to call the intruder out, triggering a siren and a spotlight, and dispatching police if necessary.

If someone had started yelling through a speaker and blasting a siren, those thieves definitely would've bolted. That's real security. That's the kind that gives you peace of mind, knowing trouble gets stopped before it even reaches your.

Jen Harbinger: Right now you can get 50% off any new SimpliSafe system at  simplisafe.com/jordan. .

Again, that's simplisafe.com/jordan. There's no safe like SimpliSafe.

Jordan Harbinger: Hey, folks, if you love the show, you'll love our newsletter as well. It's a short two minute read every Wednesday, almost every Wednesday from me to [00:24:00] you. It's something that you can apply right away, right out of the box that'll change your psychology and your decision making skills.

It is a great companion to the show. Jordan harbinger.com/news is where you can find it. Now back to Skeptical Sunday. Just take my mind off of this with something less disgusting.

Like murdering innocent people.

MIchael Regilio: Okay, let's go back to the disgusting antisemitism. Yes. Yeah, please. So, okay. So as you'll see, it's not so much about blaming the Jewish people, although a disproportionate number of conspiracy theories do just that. It can be about Ingroup and Outgroup plus a whole host of other reasons that we are about to get into.

Jordan Harbinger: We need to push this chapter of history behind us, but it doesn't seem like we're headed in that direction.

MIchael Regilio: Oh, no. I wish we could, but we have not because there's no way we could do an episode about conspiracy theories without getting into the one that is still reverberating through many hate groups today.

And that is one of the ugliest of them all the protocols of the Elders of [00:25:00] Zion,

Jordan Harbinger: which sounds fake, but yeah, you're right. We gotta cover that one. It's terrible. I know a bit about it. The protocols of the elders of Zion is one of the most infamous and dangerous conspiracy theories ever. I know that sounds like an exaggeration, but it is true.

It's based on, I think it's a forgery, right? If I'm not mistaken it. Yep. And it pretty much became the foundation for modern antisemitism. We're doing a, a whole episode on antisemitism, so this might be like a sneak preview or a sneak review depending on when this and that episode comes out.

MIchael Regilio: So it was first published in 1903 in Russia.

It claims to be the secret minutes of a meeting of Jewish leaders who are plotting to take over the world by, and here comes the laundry list of disgusting, antisemitic tropes, control of the banks and the media undermine Christianity. Foment revolution weaken the world's governments. Establish global dominance and build space lasers so that that part's, uh, I

Jordan Harbinger: assume that part's fake.

Yeah, the laser part. Yeah, sorry. Okay.

MIchael Regilio: You said the episode was getting a little dark and I [00:26:00] thought maybe we'd have a little laugh there because

Jordan Harbinger: I was like, wow. They even knew then I then my brain realized that that's, yeah. Even dumber than the original conspiracy theory. Okay.

MIchael Regilio: Okay. So there are fewer conspiracy, the crazier than Marjorie Taylor Green's Jewish space lasers.

But unlike Marjorie Taylor Green's laughable Jewish space lasers conspiracy theory, the protocols of the elders of Zion was widely believed and has done immense immeasurable harm to the Jewish community. I

Jordan Harbinger: mean, just about every hate group there is still believes it from the KK, K to the modern Nazis to.

Islamic extremist groups. Again, not known for critical thinking skills. It, it's kind of the definition of the term zombie lie. It just won't die no matter how obviously nonsense it is.

MIchael Regilio: You're a hundred percent right. Here's the truth about it, and maybe we can help put a wooden stake through the zombie's heart or however it is.

You kill zombies. Historians traced it back to the OK Ranana, which was the Czarist Russian Secret Police. They plagiarized sections from the French political satire. Maurice Riz [00:27:00] dialogues in hell between Machiavelli and Montesquieu. Which had absolutely nothing to do with Jews at all. But Russian Secret Police just inserted Jewish people into this play and created a forgery.

It was meant as propaganda to blame Jews for Russia's problems and to deflect from rising unrest against the Czar.

Jordan Harbinger: But it was just, it seems like too damn convenient of a way of scapegoating the other, so hateful groups just latch onto this. It's kind of amazing 'cause the secret police were probably like, we're gonna use this this year for this little marketing campaign we're gonna do maybe next year.

And it's like hundreds of years later. It's like, oh, this is front and center. It's crazy. Tribal brains, man. That's our

MIchael Regilio: tribal brains.

Jordan Harbinger: Yeah.

MIchael Regilio: But the text, I mean, it just went around the world. It was translated into multiple language. Uh, the Nazis embraced it, as did Henry Ford, of course, who reprinted it in his deeply anti-Semitic newspaper, the Dearborn Independent.

Side note, did you know this Hitler had a picture of Henry Ford [00:28:00] hanging in Hitler's office? Wow. How is that for a wall of shame? Geez. And that little newspaper where he reprinted the protocols of the elders of Zion, there was a time when every newly purchased Ford came with a copy of that newspaper sitting on the front seat.

Jordan Harbinger: Can you imagine being a Jewish guy who buys a new car and you're like, what did I just do? So, geez, that makes me want to check and see. It is like, if Ford is a sponsor, actually, who cares? Shamefully insane. Didn't Henry Ford recant some of this? Or is that an urban legend? Because Ford was like, we gotta, we gotta come up with a something here.

I don't think so. Henry Ford is

MIchael Regilio: one of the most notorious antisemites in American history. Oh my God. If he recanted any, uh, perhaps a listener can get back to us about that. I did not come across that in my research.

Jordan Harbinger: It almost doesn't matter. At some point it's like the damn, you do a ton of damage. You can't just be like, ah, turns out it was wrong about the Jews anyway.

Buy some Ford stock.

MIchael Regilio: Yeah, I mean the stories of Henry Ford are pretty crazy. People say like that. He was obsessed with it. [00:29:00] Like they would say that they'd go on camping trips and like they would sit around the campfire with marshmallows or whatever and Henry Ford would be like, no, but seriously, I gotta tell you about the Jews.

And they were like, oh dude. Again, with the like deeply anti-Semitic individual.

Jordan Harbinger: Yeah, that's really gross. He needed a famous comedian to sit across the table from him and be like, you really think the Jews are doing all this stuff? You might be the dumbest billionaire I've ever met.

MIchael Regilio: We didn't have real standup comedians back then.

Sadly so. Yeah. In fact, it's interesting you should say that though, because after a certain tech billionaire who's very famous right now made some questionable hand gestures, his car company stock dropped. You may have heard about that. And I had a friend who was about to buy one, and he called me up and he was like, I can't do it, dude.

I don't wanna buy a Nazis car. And I was like, you mean afford?

Jordan Harbinger: Wow. Yeah. Actually, I'm looking this up right now. There's an apology that he didn't sign that they think might have been a forgery and like he issued this apology or [00:30:00] whatever. But after the apology, he continued to privately express antisemitic views. And in 1940 was like, I hope to republish the International Jew again sometime, which is basically the, you know, yeah.

Oh, I forgot.

MIchael Regilio: I mean, I left that out, but, uh, that's worth mentioning the Dearborn Independent, uh, which I believe was an already existing newspaper and he purchased it. It says that is essentially correct. In 1919, Henry Ford bought a small newspaper in Dearborn Mission Cooking called the Dearborn Independent from 1920 to 1927, he used the paper to publish a long running series of anti-Semitic articles.

Those articles were later collected and published in a book form the International Jew. So it, the book was International Jew, but he was just taking, um, articles from the Dearborn Independent,

Jordan Harbinger: the International Jew. Sounds like kind of a nice nickname until you realize it's it's actually a book romantic.

I know.

MIchael Regilio: I'm surprised there's not some TikTok influencer out of Tel Aviv,

Jordan Harbinger: right? Like I'm the international Jew. Look at me, I'm in Dubai, chilling. I'm gonna Vegas next weekend. No, no, that's not what we mean, pal. So anyway, what a mess. So many companies have had to change their name or their [00:31:00] logos after getting some bad press.

I suppose it really speaks to America and our own history with prejudice. That Ford just kept on trucking. It was kind of like, yeah, let's ignore the whole Nazi thing, keep buying these cars

MIchael Regilio: after he died. It would've been so little effort to just change the name. I mean, I remember Dotson changed its name to Nissan, if I'm not mistaken, in my lifetime.

Oh

Jordan Harbinger: yeah, Stein. It's not that hard. Gotta make up for the past.

MIchael Regilio: Okay, so look, we're gonna find out that many conspiracy theories are pretty disgusting. We will of course, have to get into the king of conspiracy theories, who you already alluded to, Alex Jones. Mm-hmm. And some of the absolutely vile things he said about such things as the God this makes me sick.

The Sandy Hook Elementary massacre. Yeah. So let's actually, let's go ahead and mix in a few, one fun ones along the way. Have you heard the one that Donald Trump is a time traveler?

Jordan Harbinger: No, I have not heard that. Donald Trump of all people is a time traveler. Let me guess. Donald Trump comes from the future.

MIchael Regilio: No, he comes from the [00:32:00] past and this one is actually pretty funny.

Okay. Sadly, though, there are people who believe it, but the theory itself is hilarious. The theory comes from two 19th century books by American author Ingers, Saul Lockwood, who in 1893 wrote Barron Trump's marvelous Underground Journey. Whoa. In this book, the Hero is Baron Trump, a wealthy boy who lives in Castle Trump.

And embarks on adventures guided by a master of all masters named Don. That

Jordan Harbinger: is actually an amazing coincidence. I mean, Trump's son, as many of us know, is named Baron, and the boss man in the story is named Don. I, I mean that conspiracy theory, I could see why that is. Legs,

MIchael Regilio: oh, we're not even close to being done discussing the coincidences in these two books.

In the other book, the last president, New York City, erupts in chaos after an outsider is elected president of the United States protestors attack the old Fifth Avenue Hotel, which happens to be more or less where Trump Tower stands [00:33:00] today.

Jordan Harbinger: Wow. So that is too coincidental. And by the way, I mean that colloquially, I don't mean, whoa.

It's too coincidental, man. That does not, you know, mean he's a time traveler, but that is crazy. I will, I will give you that.

MIchael Regilio: Oh, well, let me get to the time traveler part, because the plot thickens and even includes Tesla, the OG Tesla, that is Nicola Tesla. It just so happens that after Tesla, the mad scientist, so to speak, passed away, his papers were reviewed for the United States government by none other than Professor John Trump of MIT.

Jordan Harbinger: I've heard Donald Trump talk about his uncle, the MIT professor. Is this the same guy? That guy's real I was. I just thought that that was not even a real person.

MIchael Regilio: Oh, well no, it is the same dude, and it cracks me up when Donald Trump talks about like his bonafide, like how intelligent he is. He's like, 'cause of my connection to MIT, it's like not your connection to your uncle's.

We all don't get to claim our uncle's fame. But anyway, that's fine. That's funny. As the story goes, and this is true, so John Trump's. [00:34:00] Examining Tesla's works, and he comes across Tesla's hidden work on time travel, and that secret fell into the Trump family's hands, and they've been bending space and time ever since.

Jordan Harbinger: That's insane. You're right. That is a fun conspiracy theory to an extent,

MIchael Regilio: except it fell into the hands of Q Anon. And again, I don't think we could have a conversation about conspiracy theories without getting into Q anon. So what the hell? Let's do it now.

Jordan Harbinger: Didn't everything q whatever predicted basically failed to come true.

I, I haven't heard anybody call themselves Q Anon in a long time. I thought they kind of hung it up.

MIchael Regilio: Now, Jordan, we both know conspiracies never go away. They just put on a new gown and rejoin the ball.

Jordan Harbinger: Mm, I hope they call it the Q Ball.

MIchael Regilio: Bingo. Ugh. Okay, so let's start with the part that most people already know.

Q Anon kicked off in October, 2017 on the message board. Four Chan. Mm-hmm. Some anonymous posters calling themselves Q Claim to be a government [00:35:00] insider with top level security clearance. They started dropping cryptic riddles. They called them Q drops that were supposed to be clues about a secret war.

Donald Trump was fighting against a global cabal of elites.

Jordan Harbinger: I'll be honest, if it wasn't for conspiracy theories, I don't think I'd even know the word cabal. Maybe a tall cabal all the time. I gotta start my own cabal. Jesus, the cabals on this

MIchael Regilio: guy don't make me do my Trump diatribe. We will be here all day.

Yeah. But the Q Anon story is just warming up. So at the heart of Q Anon is this idea. That the world is secretly run by a satanic cabal of politicians, celebrities, and business leaders. This group, according to Q, is involved in child sex trafficking, ritual abuse, and even the harvesting of blood of children for a chemical called adrenochrome, which they believe keeps powerful elites young and gives them [00:36:00] super powers.

Jordan Harbinger: Right? Adrenochrome all coming back to me now. Hunter Thompson talked about it in Fear and loathing in Las Vegas. A fictional work, not a medical textbook, by the way, in case anyone was confused. You're right. There is a dark side to this and it's weird. Adrenochrome. I guess matzo was too old fashioned or too obvious.

Remind me how the whole Adrenochrome Fountain of Youth thing, how does that work?

MIchael Regilio: So Q Anon believes that Hollywood celebrities torture children in order to get them to excrete adrenochrome. And before we go any further, let me tell you what Adrenochrome really is. Adrenochrome is a real chemical produced when adrenaline epinephrine oxidizes in medicine.

It's been studied since the mid 20th century. It was once thought to play a role in schizophrenia. It has been used experimentally to slow bleeding, but it is not a hallucinogen, not addictive, and not the fountain of youth that Q Anon and other conspiracy theorists swear it is. To say these people have been watching too many movies is an [00:37:00] understatement.

'cause the whole thing kind of reminds me of the film, the Dark Crystal, like the evil creatures in that film, the Skees, they harvest some sort of fountain of youth, like life force from their victims. The Lings,

Jordan Harbinger: I kind of remember that film. It's all the puppets, right? It's Jim Henson. Totally not a children's film.

Scared the hell outta me when I was a kid. Particularly there's a scene where they're extracting the life force and it's kind of like traumatizing.

MIchael Regilio: Yeah, exactly. Hollywood fantasy. They're living in fantasy and trying to force Hollywood fantasy into reality. And speaking of reality, adrenochrome is just a boring chemical with a limited medical history, not the magical substance that they claim it is.

Jordan Harbinger: They say history repeats itself, and I'm starting to see some echoes of the blood libel here, right? The whole, we're getting the adrenochrome from killing children, I mean torturing children, whatever. That's, it's so obviously the same thing.

MIchael Regilio: Yeah. It's just become a modern twist on blood libel. An update on the old antisemitic myth that Jews murdered Christian children for ritual purposes [00:38:00] instead of blood from Matza, it's adrenochrome from, or immortality, and once again, actual harm can come from this.

By the way, when I was researching this, I saw footage from a Q Anon, what would I call it? Forum, I suppose. And one of the people pushing this whole Hollywood celebrities are harvesting Adrenochrome from children. Nonsense is Jim Kiesel, who played Jesus Christ in Mel Gibson's the passion of Christ. He also starred in this sound of freedom.

Jordan Harbinger: Yeah, so Jim Kiesel is a nutcase. They pitched him for the show and I was like, no, I can't. I've seen interviews with him. He's just a loony tune. So a Hollywood celebrity pushing the idea that other Hollywood celebrities are dangerous. That is ironic. I can dig it actually. Ridiculous.

MIchael Regilio: Yeah. Well this, the whole thing is dangerous.

It helps reaffirm to these people that they are correct. So as you can see, if you really believe in this. You'd probably do some pretty extreme things to stop it from happening, which is why some Q Anon believers have committed violent acts.

Jordan Harbinger: I, I haven't really heard about the violent acts, I don't [00:39:00] think.

MIchael Regilio: Okay. So there was Matthew Wright, a Q Anon follower. He blocked the Hoover Dam with an armored vehicle demanding the release of a supposed government report. And he was arrested after a standoff with the police and later sentenced to seven years in prison.

Jordan Harbinger: He blocked the bridge, I assume, because if he blocked the Damn, that's impressive.

If you're doing it with one car. Yeah. Yeah, good point. But yeah, let, so let me guess. The government report that he wanted to see never existed and it was a bunch of nonsense. It's cr I You think I would've heard about this? Maybe I just don't follow the news enough 'cause I don't remember that.

MIchael Regilio: No. A lot of 'em got by me, as did the Q Anon kidnapping two Q Anon Believers in Oregon were arrested after kidnapping one of the women's biological children who she did not have custody of at the time.

Probably 'cause the child's mother was, yeah, a Qan Anon believer

Jordan Harbinger: stuff is not going well for her. Exactly. Yeah.

MIchael Regilio: But they kidnapped this child, convinced the child was being trafficked by a cabal.

Jordan Harbinger: Oh gosh, no. They're called foster parents and it's because you're crazy, Leanne. Jewish Space Lasers fake. These sponsors real, but at least they [00:40:00] save you money.

We'll be right back. This episode is sponsored in part by Quilt Mind. If you're running a business, you're building a career, you're trying to stay relevant in your industry. LinkedIn is not optional anymore. It's where decision makers hang out, not just recruiters and hiring managers, but investors, collaborators, potential clients.

And whether you realize it or not, they are checking you out, and that's why I've been working with Quilt Mind. For me, it wasn't just about chasing likes or building a huge audience. It was about making the right people take me seriously and getting noticed. LinkedIn has become a kind of professional billboard, and if you, if you're not actively shaping how you show up there, you're leaving some opportunity on the table.

Really, quote, mine makes it ridiculously simple. We talk for 30 minutes a week, they pull out stories inside. Stuff I didn't even think was post worthy. Turn it into smart strategic content that actually sounds like me and the ROI it, it's real. I've had speaking invites. Partnerships start just because somebody saw a post and thought like, oh, this guy's not a dumb ass.

You don't need 50,000 followers. You just need a smart strategy and someone to execute it for you. Hit up Jordan audience@quiltmind.com to get started. This episode is also [00:41:00] sponsored by Shopify. Starting a business always sounds exciting until you realize how much you suddenly have to figure out. Having a great product idea is the easy part, but turning that idea into an actual business, that's where it gets tricky, and that's exactly where Shopify comes in.

That's the sound of a Shopify sale. Shopify powers millions of businesses around the world. 10% of all e-commerce in the US runs on it. Big names like Mattel and Gym Shark use it, but it's also the go-to for small businesses that are just getting started. The reason is simple. Shopify makes everything easier.

You can choose from hundreds of templates to build a professional looking online store. They're built in. AI tools can write product descriptions, headlines even help clean up your product photos. Shopify also makes it simple to run email and social campaigns. And behind the scenes, Shopify can handle inventory, payments, shipping returns.

All the stuff that usually gives small business owners the biggest headaches. So whether you're just starting out or ready to scale, Shopify has everything you need to make it happen. If you're ready to sell, you're ready for Shopify.

Jen Harbinger: Turn your big business idea into with Shopify on your side. Sign up for your $1 [00:42:00] per month trial and start selling today at  shopify.com/jordan.

Go to shopify.com/jordan shopify.com/jordan.

Jordan Harbinger: I've got homes.com is a sponsor for this episode. homes.com knows what when it comes to home shopping. It's never just about the house of the condo, it's about the homes. And what makes a home is more than just the house or property. It's the location. It's the neighborhood.

If you got kids, it's also schools nearby parks, transportation options. That's why homes.com goes above and beyond To bring home shoppers, the in-depth information they need to find the right home. It's so hard not to say home every single time. And when I say in-depth information, I'm talking deep. Each listing features comprehensive information about the neighborhood complete with a video guide.

They also have details about local schools with test scores, state rankings, student teacher ratio. They even have an agent directory with the sales history of each agent. So when it comes to finding a home, not just a house, this is everything you need to know all in one place. homes.com. We've done your homework.[00:43:00]

Thank you so much for listening too and supporting the show. All of the deals, discount codes, and ways to support the podcast are on the website searchable and clickable at Jordan harbinger.com/deals. Please consider supporting those that support the show. Now for the rest of skeptical Sunday. It sucks to think about people literally out there just ruining their lives over crap that they read on the internet on Twitter mostly.

MIchael Regilio: Right. Well, I guess it's a good time to start talking about why people believe. Let's go ahead and start with the first motivation that we've already mentioned, money, which gets me back to the king of conspiracies, Alex Jones, and the turning the frogs gay

Jordan Harbinger: right

MIchael Regilio: now. Look, I'm not saying that Alex Jones is not a lunatic who believes half the crap he's saying, but his motivation to keep pushing it and believing it is clear, it's the giant paycheck.

The entire empire. He's built around conspiracy theories.

Jordan Harbinger: Yeah. It reminds me of that famous Upton Sinclair quote from the jungle. Something like, it's difficult to get a man to understand something when his salary depends [00:44:00] on his not understanding it. Exactly,

MIchael Regilio: yes. And in Joan's case, the damage he's done is hard to even fathom.

He literally tortured the parents of Slains six year olds after they were murdered at Sandy Hook Elementary. By pushing the whole Sandy Hook was a hoax conspiracy theory, and he claimed that the parents were crisis actors. Some of these just devastated parents even had to change careers and move multiple times because they were being stalked and harassed by Alex Jones fans.

Jordan Harbinger: It's so disgusting. I can't deal with that. If we hang out on this subject, I'm gonna lose it. I mean this, this a parent's worst nightmare and then compounded by people telling you that it's a bunch of crap and showing up at your workplace and your other kids' school or, it's one of the worst things I can imagine, actually.

MIchael Regilio: Yeah, Jones has real power and anyway, so let's talk about another one where he riled up his base. Uh, it was called the pizza Gate where he pushed again that elites, in this case [00:45:00] Hillary Clinton and her crew were trafficking children out of a pizza parlor's basement. This might have made for good clickbait for Jones, but one of his gullible followers showed up at the pizza place with a loaded gun.

Fortunately no one was

Jordan Harbinger: hurt. Right?

MIchael Regilio: Well, the poor app, we believe Jones did four years in prison. Right. Spoiler alert, he was killed in a routine traffic stop a few years ago when he pulled a gun on the cops.

Jordan Harbinger: Uh, okay. So he was a nut already, obviously,

MIchael Regilio: right. And that's kind of one of the most dangerous things about these conspiracy theories.

They rile up the nutcases. It's not so much that Alex Jones fans went nuts as much as the nuts went. Alex Jones fan. Yeah. So let's move into why people believe and no, it's not because lizard people really are ruling the flat earth. It's because our brain's ability to find patterns gives us an evolutionary advantage,

Jordan Harbinger: right?

Our ability to notice the migration patterns of animals, for example, our ability to notice weather [00:46:00] patterns, stuff like that, made it easier to survive as a species. And once we could perceive and maybe predict the regularity in the natural world, right? Patternicity or whatever,

MIchael Regilio: exactly. And our brain's ability to find patterns became increasingly sophisticated with the expansion of our cerebral cortex, particularly again, the prefrontal cortex.

The thing is the brain is so good at seeing patterns. It will see them even when they're not there. This is mostly benign from a person on the planes of Africa point of view.

Jordan Harbinger: In other words, we're wired to connect the dots even when the dots are maybe not even really there in the first place.

MIchael Regilio: Right? It's called hyperactive pattern recognition.

There's a well-known study by a psychologist, Jan Vi Von Perian, in which he examines the link between conspiracy belief and illusionary pattern perception, specifically spotting patterns. In random coin flips, participants were asked to observe completely random coin flips. The study showed that those who saw a pattern in the coin flips we're far more likely to [00:47:00] endorse conspiracy theories.

Jordan Harbinger: It kind of reminds me of gamblers, the whole notion of like hot streaks or, you know, I've lost the last five times, I'm due for a win, so I put more on the next round. It's like kinda like that thing.

MIchael Regilio: Yeah, you're exactly right. Superstitions of all sorts are connected to our hyper pattern Recogni. In another study, participants were shown chaotic, but meaningless paintings.

People with a higher tendency to believe in conspiracy theories, were more likely to see patterns in the paintings as well. And here's where it gets like super interesting. There's a direct correlation between people with higher dopamine levels and conspiracy beliefs.

Jordan Harbinger: Dopamine, the neurotransmitter, right?

Yeah. It's

MIchael Regilio: part of the brain's reward system. You know, every time you do something beneficial from an evolutionary point of view, the brain gives you a little reward with dopamine. Anyone that heard our episode on high speed internet and porn addiction knows that that's basically what's going on there.

They're addicted to the dopamine release, their brain is giving them. And, uh, studies show that people with conspiratorial minds have naturally higher dopamine [00:48:00] levels and get this in one study, and this wasn't a hundred percent conclusive, but it showed that people who don't have conspiratorial minds when given a boost of dopamine, become more conspiratorial in their thinking.

Jordan Harbinger: That is so fascinating. So people may be predisposed to believe in conspiracy theories because of their neurochemistry. That's crazy.

MIchael Regilio: Yeah. In fact, EEG studies show conspiracy believers tend to have reduced beta frequency oscillations.

Jordan Harbinger: What are beta frequency oscillations?

MIchael Regilio: They are frequency oscillations that get off on watching other frequency oscillations bang their wives.

Jordan Harbinger: There. You could not resist. Only a percentage of the audience is gonna get that joke, but I've Oh my, okay. What are,

MIchael Regilio: what are they really? Okay. Okay. In truth, beta activity is associated with cognitive control. Lower beta means those brains filter less noise, allowing more random associations to feel meaningful.

Jordan Harbinger: So it never [00:49:00] really occurred to me that it might be someone's brain chemistry that leads them to believe in conspiracy theories. I, I kind of, I thought it was, you know, from personal experience. Well, I should say observation. People who felt powerless in the world, you know, life's not really working out for them.

So they believe in all this ridiculous crap to get control or make sense of things.

MIchael Regilio: Yeah. And you'd be correct about that, or at least partially correct. There are many reasons people believe in conspiracy theories. Neurochemistry is just the tip of the iceberg. The iceberg. That's definitely not melting because climate change is a globalist hoax.

Jordan Harbinger: Damn globalist. We'll see how tough they are when we cut off their adrenochrome supply.

MIchael Regilio: So people that tend to believe in conspiracy theories fall into a number of categories. They are people that feel ostracized or excluded, like you just mentioned, groups with lower social status, like economically disadvantaged people, people that see themselves as victims.

People that see themselves as great but are resentful that the world doesn't agree. And this one blew my mind because it really spoke to America like in 2025. [00:50:00] People on the losing side of politics.

Jordan Harbinger: Yeah, I can personally vouch for that. I've watched some of those crazy conspiracy theories from the right.

Slowly drift over to the left in the last few months.

MIchael Regilio: Yes. And studies show that conspiracy theories flourish in times of despair, and sadly, the planet Earth in the year 2025 is not short on despair. We all have the motive to believe in conspiracy theories.

Jordan Harbinger: I have the motive to move to the Alaskan woods and get away from all this craziness.

Sometimes, maybe not so far north that I get to the edge of the flat earth or anything.

MIchael Regilio: Well, okay, so you're talking about motive there and experts break down motives for believing conspiracy theories into a number of categories. There's the epistemic motive, the existential motive, and the social motive.

Let's break it down, starting with the epistemic motive. The word epistemic comes from the Greek word for knowledge. People are motivated to understand and explain the world and reduce the chaos. People turn to conspiracy theories because they offer answers when the world feels [00:51:00] confusing. The epistemic motive satisfies a very deep evolutionary drive.

The equation kind of goes like this, understand the environment

Jordan Harbinger: survive longer. So it's like, why did the towers fall on nine 11? Because shadowy dark figures plan the whole thing. And if I wanna survive in a world where that's the case, I, I gotta understand what they're up to.

MIchael Regilio: Exactly. Conspiracies offer a clear, intentional story rather than chaos.

Believing in conspiracies allows a person to feel in the know, like a young Michael Lio did when it came to the topic you just mentioned, the towers falling on September 11th.

Jordan Harbinger: I still can't believe that My skeptical Sunday co-host was a nine 11 truther. You're, you're actually not the only one. Nick Powell, also a skeptical Sunday co-host was also a nine 11 truth or decades ago, so I'm kind of outnumbered over here.

You said something really interesting, which is that conspiracy theories they offer, there's a plan rather than just like, Hey, we maybe are kind of at the [00:52:00] mercy of the whims of our government being incompetent, or like people trying to blow up buildings in New York. It could be like a failure to have a plan, the failure to get it together, but that's scarier than a dark cabal pulling the strings.

So isn't it true that people also tend to believe that big events have big causes? Like when an event is big and the cause is not proportional, we just sort of instinctively reject these answers? I am thinking the JFK assassination is kind of top of mind. 'cause my friend covered it in a book I read that one of the reasons people rejected the official account is that one lone dude took out the most powerful person in the world.

It's just, it's utterly unsatisfying. There's gotta be more to it.

MIchael Regilio: Yeah. And you're a hundred percent correct. That's called the proportionality bias, and you just summed it up perfectly. The proportionality bias speaks to a fear of chaos and randomness. A massive conspiracy of powerful people lined up with the murder of a president.

People feel safe because that [00:53:00] makes sense. The fact of the matter is sometimes reality offers up some very bizarre coincidences that our minds just insist on connecting, which gets me to what psychologists call the epistemic closure. It reduces anxiety. But at the cost of accuracy, the next motive on the list, uh, that I just mentioned is the existential motive.

Do you care to take a guess what that's all about?

Jordan Harbinger: I'm guessing that again has to do with survival, like basic human needs for safety, security control. Existential stiff,

MIchael Regilio: right? And you'd be correct as existential here refers to feeling safe. Believe it or not, believing the powerful people, as we just said, are secretly in charge, is less terrifying than believing that bad things happen randomly and no one is in control.

People feel like if they know who's pulling the strings, they can resist. It transforms a person from a victim to a hero, which is exactly what I was feeling watching loose change.

Jordan Harbinger: I see. Well, you can always get a dog, Michael. They'll look up to you. They'll [00:54:00] treat you like a hero just for feeding them or showing up at the door.

No need to feel like you're taken on the deep state or whatever it was you were feeling, watching loose change. It's all, the other thing that's humorous to me is it's like you are gonna take on the deep state, like you got a part-time job taking tickets at the Laugh Factory on Fridays. Like you might not be the man for the job.

Right?

MIchael Regilio: We talked about lonely people, and that kind of gets to the next motive that we, the psychologists talk about, which is the social motive. Believing in conspiracy theories fulfills people's social needs, much like owning a dog. A person feels accepted and loved.

Jordan Harbinger: Now that one I have personally witnessed.

If you've ever seen a couple of conspiracy theorists growing down at a party, they are, it's like a tight knit group man.

MIchael Regilio: Yeah. And they have a text chain that they, that got going together. Once you buy into conspiracy theories, you buy into a social group. Hell, I'm sure they have pizza parties on Friday nights

Jordan Harbinger: in a secret pizzeria basement somewhere.

Perhaps.

MIchael Regilio: Yeah. Maybe they're over pizza. Since they got kind of burned on that one, they did. Maybe [00:55:00] conspiracy theorists have taco night. I don't know. But look, having friends boosts oneself image and nothing brings a group closer together than having a common enemy.

Jordan Harbinger: Sure. The deep state, the lizard people or the Jews, or I and I, or I can't believe I know this term, the Glo,

MIchael Regilio: check out Jordan with his knowledge of flat earth jargon.

That's right. You're right. Being a conspiracy theorist can bring people happiness, but ultimately the harm far outweighs the good, like the strain it can have on one's family. There are many stories of people ostracized by their family because of their extreme conspiracy beliefs. It can also lower one's sense of autonomy.

People who believe in conspiracy theories are less likely to take part in civic responsibilities like voting.

Jordan Harbinger: Okay. This is the part of the episode where you tell us what can be done.

MIchael Regilio: Yeah. I don't know.

Jordan Harbinger: Okay, but what do you mean you don't know? You did all the research. You know what can be done to help people from falling into conspiracy theories?

MIchael Regilio: I did read a lot of advice about this and I came [00:56:00] across some that I just thought was terrible advice. I heard one expert say, do your own research. No, my jaw hit the ground. I was like, that's exactly what they think they're doing. Yes, that's the problem. I did my own research is practically the mantra of every conspiracy theorist.

Jordan Harbinger: Yeah, no, I can see that. Do your own research. I mean, I even at the end of the show, I say do your own research, and I had to change it to consult real experts or whatever because people were like, no, don't tell people to do their own research. That's the problem. It's not great advice when you have no idea how to evaluate credible sources.

'cause do your own research means my doctor said one thing, but then I found a TikTok and a video on YouTube that said the other thing, so you know, I'm gonna go with that.

MIchael Regilio: Exactly. One thing I can tell you that you shouldn't do, or at least that psychologists say you shouldn't do, and as a comedian, I have to be honest with you, not gonna follow this advice, but they say don't make fun of them.

Why? Ridicule can drive people deeper into conspiracy theories.

Jordan Harbinger: Okay. I could see that. Although it certainly seemed to work out when famous comedian dude [00:57:00] rose to the shit outta you in front of your girlfriend. What about maybe helping people find other social groups and acceptance in non conspiracy theory friend groups?

Like if all your friends are on the flat Earth, Reddit and going to those conventions, maybe get into video games or something instead.

MIchael Regilio: Yeah, for sure. And that definitely works on a personal level. And if you have somebody in your life that's losing a grip on reality because of conspiracy theories, that's the exact kind of thing you can do.

But as a society, I mean, I guess we do have wonderful people who go and read to the elderly. I suppose a similar loving person could go hang out with lonely conspiracy theorists. But again, sorry, that ain't gonna be me just keeping it real.

Jordan Harbinger: Probably ain't gonna be me either.

MIchael Regilio: Look, if society does have a role in combating conspiracy theories, it's probably in the schools because it's not about what they think, it's about how they think.

And we've all heard that before, and clearly we need only look at the United States of America in the year [00:58:00] 2025 to see that there is something in our schools that has failed us. Critical thinking is key. So in a sense, I guess it's about doing your own research, but it's about knowing how to do your own research, how to weigh evidence.

We can't send everyone over 25 back to school to learn how to do critical thinking. So I don't know what we're gonna do.

Jordan Harbinger: No, we can't. I'm not sure why public education has failed us like this, unless of course it's all connected. Man hits blunt.

MIchael Regilio: No, no, no, no. Jordan, don't you start now. Yeah. Look, here's what I tell conspiracy theorists, if a scientist proved climate change was fake, or a journalist exposed celebrities drinking adrenochrome, they wouldn't be silenced.

They'd win a Nobel a Pulitzer and be filthy rich. The motives run in the opposite direction than you think they do. Human nature is to dig, to expose, to find the truth. If the earth were flat, I'd wanna know. The only evidence I see is that you, my friend, the [00:59:00] conspiracy theorist, you check every box on what we know the profile of a conspiracy theorist is.

Jordan Harbinger: So what have we learned? Conspiracy theories are as old as people from poison wells to pope plots to Q anon. The names change, but the pattern really doesn't. It's fear tribalism and the need for control. And sure, it's easy to laugh at the crazy stuff. Time traveling trumps Jewish space. Lasers, it's comedy gold.

But if you peel it back, you find something quite a bit darker. Families torn apart, lives wrecked, even violence, all because all lie kind of just made someone feel special or chosen or powerful. Here's the takeaway. Be skeptical, but not cynical. Question, authority. But don't mistake your paranoia for wisdom.

Real truth doesn't need secret handshakes or coded messages. It needs evidence, logic, and yeah, maybe a little humility, which is sadly why the truth rarely trends. And if all else fails, just remember, if the source of your information uses the [01:00:00] word Glo, maybe don't copy their notes for science class. And if you happen to run into Michael Lio, make sure you roast the shit out of him for those crazy beliefs about the moon landing.

MIchael Regilio: Or don't. You

Jordan Harbinger: might just push me into starting

MIchael Regilio: my own

Jordan Harbinger: cabal. Just join mine. Thanks Michael. Thanks everyone for listening. Topic suggestions for future episodes of Skeptical Sunday toJordan@jordanharbinger.com. Advertisers discounts deals, ways to support the show all at Jordan harbinger.com/deals. I'm at Jordan Harbinger on both Twitter and Instagram.

You can also connect with me on LinkedIn. You can find Michael Lio on Instagram link to it in the show notes because as always, nobody can spell Lio Tour date's up now as well and his special war bar drops in October. This show is created in association with Podcast one. My team is Jen Harbinger, Jase Sanderson, Tadas Sidlauskas, Robert Fogarty, Ian Baird, and Gabriel Mizrahi.

Our advice and opinions are our own, and I'm a lawyer, but I'm not your lawyer. Of course. We try to get these as right as we can. Not everything is gospel, even if it is fact checked. So consult a [01:01:00] professional before applying anything you hear on the show. Don't do your old research. Consult a professional, especially if it's about your health and wellbeing.

Remember, we rise by lifting others. Share the show with those you love. If you found this episode useful, please share it with somebody who could use a good dose of the skepticism and knowledge that we dolled out today. In the meantime, I hope you apply what you hear on the show so you can live what you learn, and we'll see you next time.

Here's a trailer for another episode of the Jordan Harbinger Show with the legendary Esther Perel as she sheds light on cheating, not just being about the thrill, but about finding a part of ourselves that we've lost.

JHS Clip: Affairs also happen often in good relationships. They're not just symptoms of relationships that have gone completely awry.

Sometimes a person goes looking elsewhere, not because they wanna find someone else, but because they want to find another self nuclear family. Life is a bitch. It's really a stressful situation on people, especially if they have on top of it, young kids, pets and [01:02:00] in-laws and older parents and all the other responsibilities of life.

We were not conceived to live like this. What's going on is this. There is what people fight about and then there is what people fight for, parent and control. That's the hidden agendas of most fights. Whose decision matters most? Who has priority? Is it about care and closeness? Can I trust you? Do you have my back?

Can I rely on you and respect and recognition? Do you value me? Do I matter much of couple's life? When things begin to go a little bit awry Is putting the responsibility on the other person without paying attention enough to what can I do to make this better? Or in what way am I contributing to my partner feeling the way they do?

So it's very important. What is relational and what is individual, and where do you start to make sense of this complicated and often very painful experience

Jordan Harbinger: to hear [01:03:00] how our fights can actually make our relationships stronger and what the future holds. For love in the age of ai, check out episode 911 on the Jordan Harbinger Show.