David Smalley (@davidcsmalley) is an actor, comedian, and host of the Dogma Debate podcast, in which he — as an atheist — regularly discusses religion and politics with preachers, pastors, comedians, and people who hold different world views.
What We Discuss with David Smalley:
- How David Smalley went from spiritual believer to secular atheist.
- Why regularly challenging your own beliefs helps inoculate you against manipulation by others.
- The tactics car dealers and clergy use to corral people into compliance.
- What happens when atheists cling to faulty beliefs with the same fervor once reserved for their disavowed religions.
- How to debate in a way that might actually change someone’s mind rather than angering them to the point of doubling down on their initial position.
- And much more…
Like this show? Please leave us a review here — even one sentence helps! Consider including your Twitter handle so we can thank you personally!
(Download Episode Here)
(Subscribe to the Podcast Here)
Worksheet for This Episode
If you’re honest with yourself, you probably hold beliefs that would wither under the light of reasonable scrutiny. Maybe they were instilled in you as an impressionable child and never since questioned. Perhaps you picked up some casual indoctrination along the way that you haven’t been able to — or willing to — shake. Don’t feel bad — we all hold such beliefs. And while these beliefs are often religious or political in nature, they can present themselves in countless forms — and we should always be ready to challenge these beliefs so we can defend them if they truly serve us or shed them if they don’t.
On this episode we talk to Dogma Debate host David Smalley, an actor and comedian who’s no stranger to challenging his own beliefs as well as the beliefs of others. As someone who’s made the journey from true believer to atheist, David is well-versed in seeing both sides of an argument and engaging in civil discourse with people who hold opposing points of view — something the world may need now more than ever. Listen, learn, and enjoy!
Please Scroll down for Full Show Notes and Featured Resources!
Sign up for Six-Minute Networking — our free networking and relationship development mini course — at jordanharbinger.com/course!
MedMen is proud to be leading the way as the cannabis industry transitions from its legacy era of homegrown enterprises to an institutional phase of professional standards and practices. Experience the new normal and find your closest store at MedMen.com!
The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) reminds us to wait at the railroad crossing if the signals are on — even if we can’t see the train, it’s probably closer than we think. STOP. Trains can’t!
The Hartford Insurance Group knows there’s nothing small in small business, and it’s been protecting customers for over 200 years. Learn what it can do for you and your business at thehartford.com/smallbusiness!
One’s a comedian, one’s a radio/TV host. Together they bring you The SDR Show — a no-apologies, not politically correct, not for the faint of heart show that somehow blends the classic energy of a morning radio show into the new era of digital entertainment. Listen to The SDR Show here or where your ears enjoy podcasts most!
More About This Show
By labeling Dogma Debate host David Smalley as an atheist, you might think you already know how a conversation with him will play out before it’s even begun. The same could be said if he were labeled as a Christian. The truth is: David’s been both.
“I started in podcasting because I was listening to radio; I was listening to Christian podcasts,” says David. “I would call in to Christian shows and ask them questions, because I was still going on my journey. I started as a believer and I was sitting down with theology professors, pastors, preachers, lay Christians who were in congregations of different churches.
“I would go, ‘Hey, is Jesus the son of God, or is he the same as God?’ And the guy would give me an answer and show me scripture and prove it. And then I would switch over and talk to another friend of mine who went to a different church and he’d be like, ‘No, no, no. It’s definitely this, instead.’ And he would show me scriptures to prove it. And I was like, ‘You guys can prove anything you want with this book.’
David didn’t set out to be contrarian. In truth, he really wanted to better understand his own position so he could argue in its defense. But as his arsenal of information grew, the ground beneath it started to give way thanks to an all-too-common experience he’d have when putting Christian podcasters on the spot.
“I would ask them a question and they wouldn’t really be able to answer me,” David says. “And then they would just hang up on me and they would edit it out; I would listen to the final podcast and my question wouldn’t even be in there. And I was like, ‘Wait a minute! They’re trying to shift this narrative like they weren’t challenged with that.’
“After this happened several times, I started recording my conversations with them [so I could] comment on their blog and be like, ‘Here’s the clip of what you cut out of the show’ so nine people could see it and we could get into a debate online.”
Dogma Debate began as a forum David envisioned as a safe place for atheists and believers to discuss their differences like adults — a refreshing alternative to name-calling flame wars so prevalent across the Internet. At the same time, David resisted the urge to censor discussions that did veer into this territory, opting instead to guide it back to civility.
“When someone would [leave] a nasty comment, I wouldn’t delete it. I would leave it there, but I, as the moderator, would comment and go, ‘Do you think this is the best way to get your point across?’ And I was employing the Socratic Method to other atheists going, ‘If you’re just going to be an ass, what do you think is going to open the door for them to want to listen to you?’ And it became a teachable moment.”
As it gained steam, Dogma Debate evolved from its blog and forum format into the podcast we know today. Now running seven years strong, it’s an excellent example of how people on opposite ends of policy and belief can respectfully challenge each other from a place of curiosity — a valuable reminder to all of us that healthy debate is possible when we apply critical thinking to any topic at hand without letting our emotional associations with that topic get the better of us. When we can question our own beliefs and shelve the ones that wither under scrutiny, we also shield ourselves from being taken advantage of by others with agendas that conflict with our well-being.
Listen to this episode in its entirety to learn more about the innocent spiritual question David asked as a child that earned him a mouthful of soap, the journey that turned David from a true believer into a secular atheist, the similar tactics car dealers and clergy use to corral people into compliance, what happens when atheists cling to faulty beliefs with the same fervor once reserved for their disavowed religions, how to debate in a way that might actually change someone’s mind versus angering them to double down on their initial position, and much more.
THANKS, DAVID SMALLEY!
If you enjoyed this session with David Smalley, let him know by clicking on the link below and sending him a quick shout out at Twitter:
And if you want us to answer your questions on one of our upcoming weekly Feedback Friday episodes, drop us a line at email@example.com.
Resources from This Episode:
- Dogma Debate
- David Smalley at Patreon
- David Smalley’s Website
- David Smalley at Instagram
- David Smalley at Facebook
- David Smalley at Twitter
- Introduction to the Socratic Method and its Effect on Critical Thinking by Max Maxwell, Socratic Method Research Portal
- Revelation! 666 Is Not the Number of the Beast (It’s a Devilish 616) by Tom Anderson, The Independent
- Crystal Healer Vs. David Smalley, Dogma Debate 400
- Strawman, Your Logical Fallacy Is…
- What is Confirmation Bias? by Shahram Heshmat, Psychology Today
- How to Prime Prospects to Say “Yes” (and Make the Sale) by John Greene, PhoneBurner
- Charles Ryu | Confessions of a North Korean Escape Artist, TJHS 84
- One Year After Charlottesville’s “Unite The Right” Riots: Following Karl Popper, We Should Tolerate Intolerance, Within Reason by Mike Godwin, Prototype
- A Manual for Creating Atheists by Peter Boghossian and Michael Shermer
- Ex-Gay Christian Vs. David Smalley, Dogma Debate 396
- What Does a Reformed Racist Look Like? The Atlantic
- Pesach: Passover, Judaism 101
- How to Criticize with Kindness: Philosopher Daniel Dennett on the Four Steps to Arguing Intelligently by Maria Popova, Brain Pickings
- Rapoport’s Rules, RationalWiki
- Baptized Atheist by David Smalley
- K.T. Tatara at Twitter
- Are You Humanist? American Humanist Association
- Why Crystal Pepsi Was a Total Flop, Mashed
- Crystal Gravy, SNL
- The Wreck Story, David’s Facebook
- The Remains of David’s Car, David’s Instagram
- “It’s Just a Flesh Wound.” David’s Instagram
- A Near Death Experience, Kidnapping, and David Defends Christianity, Dogma Debate 403
- The Reason Rally
- Ian Harris: The Skeptic Comedian
- Jon Reep at Twitter
- Still Life by Emily Mann
- How Ouija Boards Work. (Hint: It’s Not Ghosts.) by Aja Romano, Vox
- Baptist Police Officer vs. David Smalley, Dogma Debate 387