Shane Snow (@shanesnow) is an award-winning entrepreneur and journalist, author of Dream Teams and Smartcuts, and the blogger who wrote How to Debate and Make Progress by Curbing Intellectual Dishonesty.
What We Discuss with Shane Snow:
- What is intellectual dishonesty, how does it undermine meaningful debate, and what can we do to recognize it in ourselves and others?
- Why the cognitive diversity of differing perspectives and open-mindedness of intellectual humility make for healthy discourse.
- The six recurring problems in discourse: dodging, logical fallacies, deception, dirty debate, little accountability, and false endings.
- What we have to gain by rooting out intellectual dishonesty when it appears in ourselves and others.
- How to pull discussions back from the brink of intellectual dishonesty and put them on an honest track.
- And much more…
Like this show? Please leave us a review here — even one sentence helps! Consider including your Twitter handle so we can thank you personally!
Discourse and debate are more effective when we learn to be honest with ourselves and curb the subtle behaviors that get in the way of trading real ideas. Iron sharpens iron and when we argue with one another in the right way, we get smarter, we hone our ideas, and we make ourselves and the world around us better for it.
In this episode, Shane Snow returns to the show (check out his first appearance here) to talk about his recent in-depth blog post, How to Debate and Make Progress by Curbing Intellectual Dishonesty. We’ll go over intellectually dishonest tricks of the trade that can confuse the issue, distract us from the real conversation, and are ultimately used to control the way we think and behave. Consider this your cognitive self-defense dojo against intellectual dishonesty. Listen, learn, and enjoy!
Please Scroll Down for Featured Resources and Transcript!
Please note that some of the links on this page (books, movies, music, etc.) lead to affiliate programs for which The Jordan Harbinger Show receives compensation. It’s just one of the ways we keep the lights on around here. Thank you for your support!
Sign up for Six-Minute Networking — our free networking and relationship development mini course — at jordanharbinger.com/course!
Disgraceland is a true crime podcast about musicians getting away with murder. If you love true crime and you love music, get ready to love Disgraceland here!
More About This Show
If you’re intellectually honest — as Shane Snow outlined in his book Dream Teams: Working Together Without Falling Apart — you’re able to collaborate with others in a way that welcomes the cognitive diversity of different viewpoints, stir up ideas with the cognitive friction that results, and have the intellectual humility to change your mind if these viewpoints turn out to be persuasively more truthful than your own. Intellectual dishonesty, on the other hand, is the opposite. Your own viewpoint supersedes whatever truths are uncovered during discourse or debate, so you’re willing to protect it in ways that aren’t quite on the level.
“Like saying things that don’t make sense as if they make sense — knowing that they don’t make sense,” says Shane. “Engaging in conversations where you’re dodging answering the question or you’re using some tricky tactic to avoid telling the truth. Those are examples of being dishonest, but it’s shaded differently than blatant lying.”
To dig deeper into just how differently intellectual dishonesty is shaded from blatant lying, make sure to set aside some time to read Shane’s very own mega-post that inspired this episode: How to Debate and Make Progress by Curbing Intellectual Dishonesty. It’s got pie charts, illustrations, videos, and facts aplenty — just make sure to hang your political hat at the door, because there’s no doubt your side of the aisle is called out to some degree! But if you want to hold your representative to higher standards for truth, why don’t you send them a copy of Shane’s article or a link to this podcast?
THANKS, SHANE SNOW!
If you enjoyed this session with Shane Snow, let him know by clicking on the link below and sending him a quick shout out at Twitter:
And if you want us to answer your questions on one of our upcoming weekly Feedback Friday episodes, drop us a line at firstname.lastname@example.org.
Resources from This Episode:
- How to Debate and Make Progress by Curbing Intellectual Dishonesty by Shane Snow
- Shane Snow | How to Work Together Without Falling Apart, TJHS 51
- Dream Teams: Working Together Without Falling Apart by Shane Snow
- Smartcuts: The Breakthrough Power of Lateral Thinking by Shane Snow
- Other Books by Shane Snow
- Shane Snow’s website
- Shane Snow at Facebook
- Shane Snow at Instagram
- Shane Snow at Twitter
- Shane Snow at Contently
- The Hatch Institute
- The Limits of Discourse as Demonstrated by Sam Harris and Noam Chomsky, SamHarris.org
- Watch Jon Stewart Call Tucker Carlson a “Dick” in Epic 2004 ‘Crossfire’ Take Down, The Hollywood Reporter
- Obama Says Republicans Tried to ‘purge’ Black Democrats from Voter Rolls in North Carolina, PolitiFact
- Your Logical Fallacy is Strawman, YourFallacy.is
- Hillary Clinton Dodges Pay to Play Question During 2016 Debate, CNN
- Tucker Carlson vs. Kurt Eichenwald Heated Interview, Fox News
- Kellyanne Conway’s Interview Tricks, Explained, Vox
- The Colbert Report
- Ex-Theranos CEO Elizabeth Holmes Says ‘I Don’t Know’ 600-Plus Times in Never-Before-Broadcast Deposition Tapes, ABC News
- Trump Dodges Birther Question on Colbert, CBS
- President Trump’s Favorite Dodge: “What About…” Time
- The Columbo Formula, The Ultimate Columbo Site
- Your Logical Fallacy is Ad Hominem, YourFallacy.is
- Edison vs. Westinghouse: A Shocking Rivalry, Smithsonian.com
- False Analogy, RationalWiki
- Your Logical Fallacy is Appeal to Authority, YourFallacy.is
- Feedback Friday | How to Rescue Your Loved One From an MLM Scam, TJHS 164
- Analyzing Trump: 15 Logical Fallacies in 3 Minutes, Teach Argument
- Your Logical Fallacy is Appeal to Emotion, YourFallacy.is
- Sloganeering, The New Yorker
- Obama, Existence of Life Beyond Earth, UFO, Aliens, MSNBC
- Motivated Reasoning, The Skeptic’s Dictionary
- A Lost Writer’s 17,000-word Essay Reveals Which Twists Were Planned Vs. Improvised, Vox
- Global Warming and Climate Change Myths, Skeptical Science
- #TBT: What is the Meaning of ‘Is’? CNN
- The $21 Trillion Pentagon Accounting Error That Can’t Pay for Medicare-for-All, Explained, Vox
- Dr. Drew Pinsky | Give the World the Best You Have Anyway, TJHS 72
- Facts, Truths, Beliefs, Opinions, and “Alternative Facts”, Psychology Today